Skip to content

Joseph Smith’s Wives: Exploring the Lived Experiences of Polygamous Marriages

Joseph Smith, the founder of the Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints, has been both revered as a religious leader and criticized for his polygamous marriages during his lifetime. This contentious issue continues to spark debates among scholars, historians, and members of the church. However, delving deep into the lives of Joseph Smith’s wives sheds new light on the complex reality behind their relationships with him. In this article, we will examine the women who married Joseph Smith, discussing their backgrounds, motivations, and contributions to the early Mormon community.

Emma Smith

Emma Hale was Joseph Smith’s first wife whom he married at age 22. Born into a prominent family, Emma received an excellent education and possessed strong intellectual abilities. She became attracted to Joseph due to his charisma and spiritual gifts, recognizing them as divinely inspired. Their marriage began in Nauvoo, Illinois, where Joseph established his own city and temple, assembling thousands of followers around him. Emma played a crucial role in supporting Joseph through thick and thin; she bore six children and managed household affairs during her husband’s frequent absences, often enduring financial hardships. Her unwavering loyalty remained constant until Joseph’s death in Carthage Jail in 1844.

Click here for more information on Joseph Smith wives.

Fanny Alger

Fanny Alger was the first woman publicly acknowledged by Joseph as his wife. Fanny was a teenaged house servant living with the Smith family when she caught Joseph’s attention. Initially reluctant to accept his proposal, Fanny eventually agreed under pressure from Joseph’s close associates. Shortly afterward, Fanny left the Smith household and moved to Kirtland, Ohio, where she gave birth to twins fathered by Joseph. After divorcing Joseph, Fanny returned to her hometown and remarried, subsequently bearing eight more children. Historically, Fanny’s relationship with Joseph remains shrouded in controversy, given the disparity between the accounts provided by different sources.

Elizabeth “Lizzie” Ann Whitmer

Elizabeth Ann Whitmer was a devout member of the Mormon faith and cousin of David Whitmer, another important figure in Mormon history. Elizabeth initially served as a scribe for Joseph, helping transcribe the Book of Mormon. When Elizabeth learned of Joseph’s prophetic calling, she requested permission to marry him to strengthen their bond further. Joseph granted her request, sealing their union in Nauvoo. Together, they had four children before Elizabeth died shortly after childbirth.

Louisa Beaman

Louisa Beaman grew up alongside Brigham Young, who later succeeded Joseph as president of the church. At age eighteen, Louisa wed James Adams, a fellow convert to Mormonism. Sadly, James passed away soon after, leaving Louisa alone and vulnerable. Seeking solace, Louisa confided in Brigham Young, revealing that she dreamt of being reunited with her deceased spouse in heaven. Upon hearing this, Brigham proposed that she marry Joseph Smith, reasoning that doing so would help fulfill her dreams. Louisa ultimately accepted, becoming Joseph’s thirteenth wife. During Joseph’s imprisonment, Louisa traveled frequently to visit him, bringing food and supplies to help sustain him.

Sarah Ann Whitney

Sarah Ann Whitney was born in Vermont and relocated to New York with her family upon joining the Mormon church. Sarah fell deeply in love with Joseph after listening to his teachings, leading her to propose marriage herself. Delighted by her offer, Joseph happily obliged. Sarah and Joseph shared a profound emotional bond, with Sarah serving as a trusted advisor and confidante. Following Joseph’s passing, Sarah moved westward to Utah Territory, where she raised her children and continued practicing her religion.

Jane Climpson McNaught

Born in Scotland, Jane immigrated to Canada at age fourteen. Soon after arriving, Jane converted to Mormonism and migrated southwards to join the church community in Nauvoo. There, Jane caught the eye of Joseph, who asked her to become his seventeenth wife. Despite initial hesitation, Jane eventually consented, going on to bear three children with Joseph. Tragically, all three infants succumbed to illness during childhood, causing great sorrow and distress for Jane and her surviving family members.

Mary Elizabeth Rollins Lightner

Mary Elizabeth Rollins came from a wealthy and influential family. As a young girl, Mary developed a keen interest in spiritual matters and joined the Mormon church while still a teenager. Mary met Joseph during one of his public lectures and was instantly smitten, asking him to marry her shortly thereafter. Joseph readily complied, welcoming Mary into his fold. While married to Joseph, Mary gave birth to two sons but tragically lost them both within months of delivery. Following Joseph’s arrest and subsequent death, Mary moved to Salt Lake City, where she devoted much of her time towards promoting women’s rights.

In conclusion, exploring the life stories of these women provides deeper insight into the complicated dynamics surrounding Joseph Smith’s polygamy practices. Each woman brought unique experiences and perspectives to their relationships with Joseph, contributing significantly to the growth and development of the nascent Mormon movement. Their stories also highlight some of the challenges faced by women during that era, including limited educational opportunities, societal expectations regarding gender roles, and restricted access to resources and decision-making power. These factors undoubtedly impacted how these women perceived and engaged with Joseph’s proposals, reflecting broader cultural norms and values that continue to shape our understanding of historical events today.